Reviews, Style
comments 4

Fitting Room Review: Everlane Luxe Cotton Dresses

Everlane luxe cotton dresses review. The same model wears three different items: a jumpsuit and two dresses.

I visited the Everlane store here in San Francisco a few times this summer and have a backlog of things I’ve been meaning to review. Will these items even be relevant once I get around to writing about them, though? Is it just me, or has Everlane increased the frequency of their new releases?

** this post contains affiliate links **

I haven’t exactly been paying attention, but it feels that way to me. It also seems like items don’t stick around as long? An example: last summer I bought the Relaxed Cotton Tank in two colors. After wearing them for a while, I realized that I should have sized down. I want to replace them, but they’re gone. This summer, Everlane released other tank tops from their Pima Stretch series (like this scoop tank top and this microrib tank top). But these fit closer to the body. Why not keep both the Relaxed Cotton items and the Pima Stretch ones since they fit differently?

I thought Everlane was all about the basics. That’s one of the reasons I shop them. I want to be able to stock up on things that I’ve already tried and that I know will work for me. But Everlane feels like any other retailer dangling shiny new things in front of me. Maybe they’re operating like Ikea, which only keeps the most popular items in production. That makes sense from a cost-of-manufacturing perspective. But I’m not going to lie: I’m a bit miffed about some of the tried-and-true staples no longer being available.

Anyhow, on to today’s review.

This summer Everlane introduced its Luxe Cotton line. I have to say, I love this fabric. It’s tightly-knit which gives it a super smooth touch, drapes nicely, and has the slightest bit of sheen. It’s thin, but not too thin. Made in this factory in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, all of the items below were originally produced in three colorways: black, a light brown called toasted coconut, and dusty blue

The Everlane model is 5’10” and wearing a small in everything.

The Luxe Cotton Midi Dress

So, this is one of the items that has already vanished. It’s sold out at the moment. No word on restocks. But I’ll write about it in case it comes back. (Or in case you’re searching for one secondhand.)

I honestly didn’t think anything of this dress when I saw it on the rack. It looked kind of boring. But then I tried it on and was surprised by the fit. Here it is on 5′ 4″ me. I’m a dress size 4 and wearing XS here. It manages to be flattering and comfy. Yes, it is way longer than me, but also partly that’s due to the angle that I’m holding my phone at. Only thing is that you’d have to wear a racerback bra or a strapless bra because it does not work with bra straps.

The Luxe Cotton Side Slit Tee Dress

Is this chic or boring? I can’t tell. There’s some creases around my post-lunch belly. Doh. Darker colors would hide that. How many black dresses is one allowed to have? Because I kind of want this in black. My Everlane Relaxed Cotton Tank Dress (another discontinued item) serves a similar purpose, though it’s more casual. This dress telegraphs a more polished look with the cap sleeves, the side slits, and the fabric.

The slits go up quite a ways (almost 13″), which is good for walking but will show a good deal of your thigh when you sit down. So, probably not office appropriate. For a shorty like me, I recommend hemming it to get the right proportions. This also came in some other colors, like the faded sage shown in the very first photo, an olive, and a light pink. But between the time I started drafting this post and actually posting it, colors have sold out.

The Luxe Cotton Jumpsuit

I knew from the photos that I wouldn’t like this but I tried it on in the name of bloggery. First of all, I’m not into patch pockets. With such a soft drapey material, this seemed like an especially odd choice to me. What would you possibly put there? Maybe a ticket? Anything heavier than that would sag the leg.

I’m wearing the small here and it’s a bit too big. (They didn’t have the XS in store.) For shits and giggles, I tried it on without the belt.

LOL. Why would anyone wear it without the belt? Oh hell no.

I just saw that Everlane also released some tops in this fabric, like this mockneck tee and the Luxe Cotton Crop Tee, which sports three-quarter sleeves and a wide neckline. I’m super curious about the latter one because “cropped” is one of my favorite words as a petite.

Overall, I really like this fabric, though I’m not sure how it would withstand wrinkles during a day of wear.


If you find my reviews helpful and are new to Everlane, please considering using my referral link to make your first purchase. (Create your account before browsing.) This helps make my reviews possible. Thank you so much! You can find a directory to all my Everlane reviews here.

4 Comments

  1. Although I don’t really shop at Everlane much anymore, even I notice how quickly some of their new-ish releases disappear! Colors and entire products just disappear without warning. One of my offline friends and I were just discussing how they had now taken away all of their (very popular, or so we had thought) classic twill backpacks. Those were a really classic and practical Everlane product, and I think they may have been around for most of the brand’s first 4-5 years in existence, if not longer? And a lot of the products I’ve liked over the years are long gone. I’m sometimes very slow about thinking through potential purchases. With how quickly Everlane discontinues some colors and designs, there’s no way I’d ever have enough time to think through potential purchases.

    I don’t personally like the direction the brand is taking. When I first became aware of them around 2012-2013-ish, they really marketed themselves as a brand that made a very small, narrow product line of versatile basics that they would continuously offer, and I really liked that idea. I wanted to be able to keep going back to get the same products years and years later. Granted, I suspect that my “ideal” brand that does that wouldn’t actually be profitable or wouldn’t be able to grow as much as Everlane has.

    • welcomeobjects says

      I’m annoyed that they also took away the classic twill totes! Same story as the twill backpack: around for many years, then disappeared. They were super practical, a step above other tote bags materials wise, and priced right. Some friends even bought their own after I raved about mine. Seems like there would always be a need/demand for them. But nope, they’re gone. I’m with you. Everlane feels more trendy than they used to be. It seems like they overproduce some products and put them on sale right away. Others sell out in colorways quickly, creating a sense of scarcity. This encourages buying for the sake of not missing out rather than a considered decision.

  2. Sara Hahn says

    i just found your blog and i love all the everlane reviews! thank you- I’m going through the archives and learning so much

    • welcomeobjects says

      Thank you so much for taking a moment to let me know! Happy to help.

Leave a Reply