Back in the fall, I noticed that Quince had a new product in their lineup: a belt bag that sure looked a lot like the Waverley from Lo & Sons. As I shared in this review, the Waverley convertible belt bag is one of my favorite bags. I own two of them (the original and the 2) and wear them often. The Waverley is a must for me on travel days as well as a convenient bag to throw on when I’m running errands.
I do not need another belt bag, but my curiosity got the best of me. Plus, in the name of bloggery, I felt it was my duty to know how this Quince version compares. So I ordered the Quince Italian Leather Convertible Belt Bag in cognac, which I hoped would go with my brown dr. Liza sandals. Here’s how it compares to my trusty Lo & Sons Waverley.
The bags in this post were given to me by the respective brands and this post contains affiliate links. If you shop through my links, I may earn a commission. As always, I decide what to write about and all opinions are my own. Thanks for the support.
Design

Lo & Sons Waverley 2 on the left, and Quince Italian Leather Convertible Belt Bag on the right.

They both feature a tapered design.
Design-wise, these bags are quite similar. The Lo & Sons has a rounder shape at the bottom while Quince is more squared off. I think the Lo & Sons has a more pleasing shape, but the Quince shape is good too.
One note of difference: on the Quince the zipper extends beyond the bag, so there’s a bit that hangs over the edge.
I found another difference in the construction of the bag. The bottom of the Quince bag appears to be one piece of leather, but on the Lo & Sons it’s several. I don’t know that one is better than the other, just noting that they’re not the same.

The bottom of the bags reveal a different construction. The Lo & Sons is made out of several pieces of leather while the Quince appears to be made of one.
Organization
In general, I’ve found Lo & Sons bags to have organization that makes sense. The interior of the Waverley has a large slip pocket on one side. On the other side is a zippered pocket, and inside of that are three card slots.
The Quince similarly has a large slip pocket on one side and a zippered pocket on the other. It has two card slots, but these are outside of the zippered area, so they are less secure.
The biggest difference, though? The Lo & Sons has a card slot on the back of the bag.

The Lo & Sons Waverley 2 has a card slot on the back, which is handy for something you might need to reach for often like a transit card or hotel key.
Leather
I was disappointed when I opened the box from Quince, mostly because the color was not what I was expecting. The leather has a dull finish to it. Quince says their bag is made out of top-grain Italian leather whereas Lo & Sons offers the Waverley in three types of leather: nappa, saffiano, and cactus.
My first Waverley bag is made out of nappa leather, which feels soft and supple.(Though one drawback of nappa is that it can scratch easily.) Saffiano has been stamped with a crosshatch finish that makes it stiffer and more scratch resistant. I can’t speak to the cactus leather since I haven’t seen it.
My non-expert impression just from feel is that Lo & Sons uses nicer leather. The top-grain leather on the Quince bag is thinner and has a more plasticy feel to it.
But is it even top-grain leather? Tanner Leatherstein recently took apart a Quince tote bag advertised as top-grain leather and his conclusion was that was a lie! He said it’s actually split leather, the lowest grade of leather. That particular bag is no longer on the Quince site, but it was made in Gurgoan, India whereas the belt bag is from a factory in Dongguan, China. So, one cannot conclude that the belt bag is also false advertising, though one does wonder.
Both brands use leather tanned in a Leather Working Group-certified tannery. But Lo & Sons specifies that their nappa leather is gold certified (the highest level) while Quince does not say what level of certification they have.

Lo & Sons Waverley 2 in saffiano leather.

Quince Italian Leather Convertible Belt Bag in top-grain leather.
Other Materials
Hardware: Quince’s hardware is a brassy gold color. Lo & Sons offers more hardware options: gold, silver, and gunmetal. The finish of the Quince hardware is more matte than Lo & Sons.
Edging: The edging on the Quince cognac bag matches the color in both the body and the strap, which is a nice touch. On both my black-colored and plum-colored Waverley bags, the edging is black. I checked photos of the Waverley in a brown, sienna, and it also has matching edging on the body, though the edging on the strap is black. However, other colors, like the dark tan, has all matching edging.

The hardware on the Lo & Sons (top) is shinier than the Quince.
Sizing
Lo & Sons’ Waverley 2 comes in two sizes: small and large. The Quince belt bag is a touch bigger than the large Waverley in all dimensions. It is also a tad heavier at .84 lbs versus .80 lbs for the Waverley — not that I can feel the difference.
Lo & Sons Waverley Large: 8.3″w x 5.9″h x 2″d
Lo & Sons Waverley Small: 8.0″w x 5.6″h x 2″d
Quince Convertible Belt Bag: 8.46″ w x 6.3″ h x 2.36″
Both brands come with two straps, a short one, and a longer adjustable one. You can add the short one to the long one to wear the bag crossbody. The strap is thicker and harder to adjust on the Quince bag.
According to my measurements (which includes the hardware on either end):
Lo & Sons Waverley
Short strap: 15.5″
Long strap: 23.75″-42.75″
Total length at longest: 58.25
Quince Convertible Belt Bag:
Short strap: 16″
Long strap: 23.75″-41″
Total length at longest: 57″
As you can see below, the sizing between the large Waverley and the Quince convertible belt bag are more or less the same. They both fit my essentials: wallet, phone, a reusable bag, packet of tissues, lip balm, and sunglasses. (See the four ways to wear a convertible belt bag here.)
Summary & Final Thoughts
Price: Not surprisingly, Quince is cheaper because that’s what they do. Their convertible belt bag is priced at $69.90.
The large Waverley is $220 retail (an increase in price from a year ago) though it often goes on sale. Right now it’s 30% to 60% off depending on the leather, which puts it at $88-$154.
Here’s a summary:
Lo & Sons Waverley 2 |
Quince Italian Leather Convertible Belt Bag |
|
---|---|---|
Leather | Nappa, Saffiano, Cactus | Top-grain Italian |
Size | Large: 8.3″w x 5.9″h x 2″d Small: 8.0″w x 5.6″h x 2″d |
8.46″ w x 6.3″ h x 2.36″ |
Weight | Large: .8 lbs Small: .6 lbs |
.84 lbs |
Strap lengths | 23″ – 58.25″ | 23.75″ – 57″ |
Price | Large: $220 Small: $210 But there’s often a sale |
$69.90 |
Quince markets itself as luxury for less, but I wouldn’t say that this belt bag feels like a luxury item. However, I do think it’s a perfectly fine minimalist bag, particularly if you favor a neutral color like taupe. (The bag also came in black, but that and the cognac are not available at the moment.)
Having used two Lo & Sons Waverley bags extensively, I know that they’re nicer with higher-quality leather. They also offer more variety. Between the types of leather, color, and hardware, there’s 22 options.
Plus, Lo & Sons is a small, family-owned business that purports to care about sustainability. How sustainable or ethical is Quince? It also makes sustainability claims, but it’s been accused of greenwashing. (See my last post where I discuss an article that does a deep dive into the brand. ) Good On You gives Quince a “not good enough” rating while Lo & Sons is not in their database.
If you can spring for the Lo & Sons, I think it’s worth it to pay more for the better product. But at $70, the Quince bag isn’t a bad option at all.